Book Review – Gavin Menzies – 1421: the year China discovered the world
In this outstanding book, retired submarine captain Gavin Menzies rewrites history and takes us on an epic adventure around the world in the company of huge Chinese fleets carrying soldiers, craftsmen and concubines.
Using a mixture of medieval maps and manuscripts, an in-depth and practical maritime knowledge, botanical evidence and sound reasoning, Menzies puts forward his theory that China, not Europe, discovered America, Australia, and the rest of the world – decades before Europeans set sail for distant seas.
In a rich and descriptive style, Menzies tells of the lives of the Emperor Zhu Di, who ordered the voyages of exploration, and of Admiral Zheng He, his friend and chief eunuch. He goes on to describes the huge treasure fleets and tracks their course across the face of the globe. At each landfall, Menzies gives evidence of the Chinese presence, delving into the folklore of the area’s inhabitants and noting the presence of Asian plants and chickens far from China’s shores, predating the first Europeans.
This book is a must for anyone interested in keeping up to date with the most recent historical discoveries. In one fell swoop, Menzies has turned the old idea that Europeans first discovered America and circumnavigated the globe on its head. The history books will have to re-written!
1421 is written in an enjoyable style and the author’s modesty about his groundbreaking work makes the reader warm to him immediately. Not only are the journeys of the Chinese ships recounted but also the author’s own travels in their wake, as he flies around the world seeking evidence of the voyages and advice from a number of experts. This gives the book a double flavour of adventure that makes it hard to put down. An interesting and well-written read.
Is there a bubble in China property (中国房产有泡沫么)
Secret for China's Growth (中国经济增长原因探讨)
China's Environmental Crisis (中国的环境威胁)
Mr China – A memoir (中国先生)
The Chinese Century (中国世纪)
Who will Feed China: Wake Up Call for a Small Planet (谁来养活中国)
Asia Hotel
WCM
#1 by Rosie of BooksAndBakes on September 10, 2009 - 2:55 AM
Quote
多谢这书评 - 我正在看,同意所有中国通应该看这本书!
Thanks for the review – I’m reading this at the moment and agree that any China-crazies should be too!
But, having said that, it is subject to criticism, and is accused of being ‘reckless’. I don’t know the facts, but I am getting that impression. Thus far, no other experts have expressed an opinion in the book, which always makes you wonder.
但是,还被学者受了批评,说它是粗的。我不知道知情,可我对这本书有了哪影响。Menzies不引别的学者,让我不太信。。。
#2 by Wushu on September 12, 2009 - 1:05 PM
Quote
my feeling is that there are a lot of conjecture and guesstimate in the conclusion of this book. Nevertheless it provides an alternative perspective to understand the impact of Zheng He’s Fleet and the history of Ming Dynasty during that time.
#3 by 林 on November 16, 2010 - 11:54 PM
Quote
我有美洲大陆是中华帝国的证据,可是被中国的权威们嗤之以鼻,我很无奈,我将山海经的五臧经画出来了,他们看都不肯看就说成是“巧合”,难道447座山都是巧合吗?我研究出了好多有关“上帝造人”的“证据”,耶和华其实是中国第一个天朝的君主叫天帝,名字是“实惟实”。天帝就是上帝,黄帝就是中帝等,还有大洪水是五千年左右时间为周期的,如今冰山融化已经进入了再次发作的前兆,可是没人相信,没人理我。我的论文两万多字的论证,说明得很清楚。可是在这里没办法发表,请帮帮我。